Touchdown for Super Bowl Automotive Ads? [2012 Edition]
By: Compete Blog
Posted on March 20, 2012 at 14:39 PM EDT
Image from: ABC News The 2012 Super Bowl has come and gone and as typical the game’s ads seemed to get as much attention as the game itself, fueled by executives touting their companies’ presence and ad snippets “leaked” in advance. Again in 2012, many advertisers were automakers. Compete compared un-aided ad recollection with changes [...]
Image from: ABC News
The 2012 Super Bowl has come and gone and as typical the game’s ads seemed to get as much attention as the game itself, fueled by executives touting their companies’ presence and ad snippets “leaked” in advance. Again in 2012, many advertisers were automakers. Compete compared un-aided ad recollection with changes in in-market automotive shopper volume to inform whether these ads were productive in driving near-term new vehicle demand. [This analysis compliments Compete’s earlier week-by-week assessment of changes in consumer behavior.]
First Down: Recollection
Compete asked 644 online consumers which auto brand first came to mind when thinking about the 2012 Super Bowl. Respondents could choose any brand. Of those that watched the game, one in five recalled seeing a Chevrolet ad; Chevrolet was #1 in 2011 as well (see 2011 analysis). Chrysler’s change from Eminem to Clint Eastwood preserved its #2 rank. Ford and Volkswagen changed spots for 2012; VW’s reveal of its famous Darth Vader spot in 2011 (11% recollection) was evidently more memorable than 2012’s follow-up (8%). Ford did not advertise in 2012 but was referenced in Chevrolet’s Apocalypse spot and related fall-out.
Second Down: Changes in Recollection
Some brands returned to Super Bowl advertising in 2012 to recapture 2011 glory, while others were new. Some built on last year’s themes; some tried something new. There was no one successful formula as Chrysler, Acura and Honda had the greatest y-o-y gains in recollection. Chrysler’s Clint Eastwood spot built on the theme of its 2011 ads. Acura’s use of Jerry Seinfeld and a Jay Leno cameo was new for 2012. Honda tried something new with the cute and quirky CR-V spot.
Third Down: Changes in Recollection vs. Changes in SMI
To connect stated recollection and actions, Compete compared 2012 top-10 ad recollection with m-o-m changes in those brands’ Share of Market Interest (SMI). SMI represents the share of all in-market shoppers market-wide that shopped a brand. Those calculations leverage Compete’s patented data and normalization process and are based on consumers actively engaged with specific vehicles. Results avoid false positives associated with double-counting consumers. A positive correlation suggests that recollection directly influences in-market shopper activity.
While recollection levels were generally similar 2012 vs. 2011, resulting consumer behaviors were not. In 2011, greater recollection generally resulted in a greater SMI. In 2012, the opposite was true and the highest recollection levels did not guarantee higher SMI gains. Arguably Hyundai did the best in that its SMI was the greatest relative to its recollection.
Fourth Down: The Rest of the Story
Football is a dynamic game year to year and the ability of Super Bowl ads to drive behavior looks to be as well. But before we write off Super Bowl ads as unproductive, more investigation is warranted:
Stock Market XML and JSON Data API provided by FinancialContent Services, Inc.
Nasdaq quotes delayed at least 15 minutes, all others at least 20 minutes.
Markets are closed on certain holidays. Stock Market Holiday List
By accessing this page, you agree to the following
Press Release Service provided by PRConnect.
Stock quotes supplied by Telekurs USA
Postage Rates Bots go here